Deliciously Creamy Homemade Baileys Irish Cream Recipe

Still in need of a neighbor gift? This is my most favorite homemade gift to give and it is always an unexpected hit. And with us, because if you're making a batch, might as well make enough to share some with yourselves too.

My in-laws shared this recipe with me after I had enjoyed some at a holiday gathering at their house and it blew my mind. I had never thought about making homemade Baileys before! It's easy to make, delightful and so fun to share!

---

Homemade Baileys Irish Cream:

• 1 can Eagle Brand sweetened condensed milk

• 1 1/2 C. Irish whiskey or bourbon

• 2 Tbl. Hershey's chocolate syrup

• 1 pint half-n-half

• 1 Tbl. light Karo syrup

• 1 mini bottle Khalua or 1/4 cup

Mix all together, refrigerate.

---

Make It Festive

I like to find cute glass jars at T.J. Maxx or wherever else I am shopping and make them festive with some bows or other Christmas decoration.

Here are a couple of great options from Amazon:

Then I add a note that says, "Naughty or Nice this season? Mix with your coffee if you're nice, or enjoy on the rocks if you're naughty."

These gift tags are a great option!

---

I am an Amazon Affiliate and can earn commission on certain purchases.

What if you got a favorite things newsletter delivered weekly to your inbox? Without feeling overwhelmed, you’ll feel informed and on top of trends, great books, popular shows, recipes, ideas and more.  You heard it on Babble.  

Share this story today!

Want more? Follow Babble on Instagram.

Hit Follow.  We’re You’re People.